I pray to the gaming gods that one day, a developer will be brave enough to make a political statement. Such as: “Nazis are the bad guys”. When will the brave step up for us gamers?
EA Is Changing the Name of a Nazi in 'Battlefield V' That Belonged to a Real-Life Resistance Fighter
2 Likes
"The aforementioned Elite, Wilhelm Franke, whose name we’re changing is not a Nazi, but a German solider similar to ones we already have in the game. In Battlefield V , we’re not making any political statements in relation to the real life events of WW2 and there are no swastikas in the game.” … Last year, after the studio released a Battlefield V story chapter following a tank crew fighting on the Nazi side, the studio clarified to the media that the chapter’s protagonist is not a Nazi, just a German, and that the chapter depicted “the German perspective.”
Does DICE know that the German soldiers in World War II were Nazis? I thought that would have come up during the research process while making a game about World War II, but maybe not. Anyway, I know from being on the Internet during the Charlottesville march that it’s extremely important to be precise in our use of the word “Nazi,” and that people who split hairs about who precisely counts as a Nazi while wearing their symbols and killing for their cause are most definitely arguing in good faith, so there’s nothing here to worry about.
2 Likes
Remember when games used to have the opposing team always look like the bad guys? And the opposing team would see YOU as the bad guys?
Man… What a time.
I mean Wolfenstein did it and got heaps of praise for clearing this incredibly high bar.
6 Likes
And then they started leaking Wolfenstein 3 and revealed one of the main characters is now running the FBI.
…yeah…
war? not political? musta listened to the latest beastcast
2 Likes
I’m just surprised to learn that Dan Ryckert apparently works in the EA PR department.
3 Likes
Wait is this true? Wtf
It is a mix of fascinating and terrifying to watch very recent well documented history be systemically converted into myth before our very eyes. I feel like in fifty years, WWII will be reduced mostly to costume and style more than actual fact.
1 Like
Yup! It’s a black woman to boot.
My initial inclination was to make a snarky comment about how ‘keep politics out of muh games’ and historical purity crowds will of course be silent on this.
But the more I think about it, the scarier it gets. The extreme Right along with bad-faith actors are so thoroughly controlling our political discourse that they’ve got ““centrists”” 1 step away from holocaust-denial talking points.
3 Likes
I’ve come to believe that the games industry largely thinks being “political” is being didactic. Like, there’s always the chance that “we’re not being political” is a marketing ploy meant to stir up conversation, but I think the white dude liberals who make up A LOT of the AAA space just genuinely believe that to have politics in a game is to have overt soapbox-y messaging
2 Likes
I am so tired…
What a bar to clear to, before even saying Nazis are bad, admit your WWII game has Nazis and hey maybe glorifying them and capitalising on Nazi aesthetic is perhaps not the greatest move.
They’ll rather double down on feigned ignorance than backing down from potential revenue.
The AAA space continues to be cynical garbage.
2 Likes
If they had done this for BF5, there would have been a “let me play as the nazis” backlash (maybe even a petition?) which would have really helped illuminate the issue for what it is on its face, rather than the vague “historical accuracy” crap they always hide behind.
2 Likes
It’s handled in a “we’re all roleplaying as our favorite team” sort of way that Battlefield Hardline treated cops and robbers, or Battlefront treated resistance versus imperials.
In the latter case, the imperials are an obvious analogue for nazis, but there was always a buffer of them being cartoonish enough villains that someone can roleplay as The Bads without onlookers questioning your judgment.
Nazis can’t and won’t every have that degree of cultural remove (for good reasons), and there’s such a heavy pall of sketchiness over people claiming to collect or wear their memorabilia, that the scenario has been played for laughs in a few comedies.
This is the logical end point of treating any potential set dressing over a gamified system as culturally inert, so long as it doesn’t have an impact over those systems.
3 Likes
I can’t find the picture, but there was parody article I saw way back that said:
Gamer Says They Don’t Want Politics in Their Games About Large-Scale Geopolitical Conflicts
3 Likes
This isn’t just games at this point. “Poiltics” in the common lexicon is becoming synonymous with “Preaching” and it’s extremely dangerous imo. It’s a not-so-thinly veiled version of the “leftist snowflake” rhetoric meant to paint anyone even vaguely progressive as a didactic influencer who wants to poison your brain.
Like I was listening to the CBC today and the Liberal Feds are picking up the slack for some of Ontario’s fash premier’s cuts to environmental programs for 4 years, conveniently the length of one election cycle and change, and apparently this wasn’t a political move.
We’re in a moment where a politician’s politics (apparently) aren’t political.
4 Likes
What the actual fuck?! “In WW2 there were nazis” is a statement now?! I don’t have a take! I aggressively refuse to have a take! “German soldier” my whole entire ass! Fuck big budget video games!
2 Likes
And even then, this isn’t some faceless, feldgrau footman that could hypothetically avoid party membership, he’s dressed like a decorated officer…
1 Like
Fascist imagery is perhaps the most recognisable and distinctive in recent memory, so you better believe EA is going to treat it like branding rather than anything with political connotations. I bet Kyle from the focus group rated that Nazi design as “Very Distinctive”.
This from the company that got reamed by gaming nazis for including playable female character and having some minor queer subtext in a cutscene. All that matters to these companies when it comes to politics is what they can co-opt in order to stand out in the market.
1 Like
