This one’s always fun. What is a game you’ve never finished and feel really guilty about not finishing?
For me, it’s Shadow of the Colossus. I love the heck out of it in every way and I even talk about it like I’m a person who’s finished it, but I never actually have. Runner-up is SMT: Nocturne. I recommend it constantly but myself am only a little over halfway through.
Note: try to mention only specific games (a huge Steam library of unplayed titles doesn’t count) and don’t make this about the games you flat-out weren’t interested in and stopped playing–that’s the opposite of shame! I’m looking for that sweet shame!