Ranking of PlayStations

With the caveat that I grew up with only Nintendo handhelds and have only really been able to explore older console games in the last couple of years, I have to go with the PS2. There’s just so much variety there in that generation of games that when I went back to play them I felt almost overwhelmed. It truly feels like big developers were able to be more experimental at that point, when games were still more of a niche interest and they didn’t have to make them as broadly palatable as possible.

4 Likes

This is way too tough for me to pick. I have such fond memories of all of these consoles and they’ve each played important roles during different parts of my life, but I think I’m going to have to settle on PS3 (PS Vita would be my runner up).

One of my most vivid memories from my entire Playstation history is from that generation, when I was at a Walmart and played Motorstorm at a demo kiosk. My brother and I used to play a bunch of those MX vs. ATV games on PS2, and this demo was a night and day difference. Along with the vast jump in visual fidelity, it just felt different in a way I can’t describe. But I knew then and there that this felt like a real generational shift and that I would be getting a PS3 (Motorstorm Pacific Rift would later become one of my and my brother’s most played games). Besides the games, another reason I love the PS3 so much is the introduction of the Playstation Network and with it, the Playstation Store, trophies, and ease of online multiplayer and connecting with people online.

1 Like

PS4 isn’t just the best gaming console I’ve ever owned in terms of raw games on the machine, but it’s the best damn Netflix, Youtube, Hulu, and HBO Go box I’ve ever had. I haven’t played a PS4 since I finished FFVII Remake three months ago, and I still turn it on every day.

I love the UI, I love the controller. I hate that it doesn’t have buttons on the front, but whatever. Solid thing.

2 Likes

I’m still a little sore that we never got the UnKarted game.

I had to sit with this one a hot minute. I have fond memories of all of them, but there’s a special place in my heart for Jak and Daxter, Ratchet and Clank, Prince of Persia, Sly Cooper, etc. Some of my favorite games ever, coming out every fall. I’m glad that my gaming tastes are a little more broad nowadays, but I’m overjoyed that the action platformer is still being kept alive by Insomniac. It feels like coming home.

1 Like

I rank as follows:

  1. Playstation 1
  2. Playstation 2
  3. Playstation 3
  4. Playstation 4
  5. Playstation 5
1 Like

My brother owned our PS2 and our parents expected us to share even though we were both horrible goblins and he put it in his room. Even so, we managed to play Jak & Daxter, Sly Cooper, Metal Gear Solid 2 & 3, God of War I & II, GTA: Vice City (Miami represent!) and San Andres, as well as Katamari Damacy. Those are the ones I can remember off the top of my head. He played a bunch of football games. It’s probably the last time I remember getting along with him. I spent most of the time the PS2 was relevant wishing I owned my own, enough so that I ended up buying my own once the PS3 came out and they dipped in price.

I never owned a PS3, but I had friends who did, and we played through SO MUCH on that console. Okami, Resident Evil 5, 6 and Revelations (1 and 2). I would go over to my best friend’s house after work or college classes and we would just cook and eat and play games. Loved those days and miss them dearly. I was later gifted a PS4 and tbh the last time I remember playing it to any intense degree was when God of War came out. I played through Prey, some of Fallout 4 (imma be real w/ y’all i only built settlements), a lot of Let It Die, very little Bloodborne and even less Nier: Automata. I generally didn’t really know what I was supposed to be getting for the PS4, and b/c I got into an MMO and the prices were generally better for games on PC, I ended up slanting hard Steam and I haven’t really fucked with a console at length ever, really. I have 0 plans to get a PS5.

My order is PS3, PS2, PS4, because as much as I loved the PS2, memory associations are a helluva thing. I didn’t own a PSX b/c I lived in South Florida and I spent most of my time back then running around outside getting as dirty as humanly possible, secure in the knowledge that my muddy clothes were a problem for my parents to solve.

3 Likes

Shadow Hearts and Shadow Hearts 2 are way underrated JRPGs on PS2. I will never stop bringing them up whenever it’s relevant and often when it’s not.

2 Likes

PS4 on top PS1 on the bottom. PS2 and PS3 are a coin flip in the middle.

I technically still have all four hooked up to my TV.

1 Like

PS2 is in argument for the best home console ever. So that’s an easy 1.
PSP is the best non Nintendo portable console ever. I’m a huge fan of portables so that’s aces.
That’s the list.
I guess for me PS1 is the next. And then PS4?
Vita and PS3 are the bottom. I could not even be bothered to own them.

1 Like

I feel like it’s:
1 1
2 3
4 5
3 2
5 4

1 Like

I gotta say, was not expecting such a lopsided result. I do wonder if it tells us anything about the average age of posters on this forum. :thinking:

1 Like

So I’ve only really played a couple of games on each PS system with the exception of the PSP, so it’s all kinda recency bias and which games I liked the most. That said:

1, Vita: Beautiful OLED screen, Wipeout 2048, Gravity Rush, done. Thought about putting it below PSP since that has more games I like and playing them on Vita is a pain, but it can still do it and I like the hardware better.

2, PSP: Definitely the PS system I’ve played the most. Wipeout Pure/Pulse, Ratchet & Clank: Size Matters, LocoRoco, Space Invaders Extreme, Persona 3 Portable (I played P4G on Vita first but P3P has held up a lot better of the two for me). Also was an impressive system before I had a DS.

3, PS3: Uh, it mostly became a Wipeout HD, SingStar and general media machine after I beat Persona 5, but it’s extremely good at those things. Oh, and I played Burnout Paradise on PS3 so that’s nice.

4, PS4: I don’t have one but I played so much Wipeout Omega Collection on a friends. So much.

5, PS1: I have never played on an actual PS1, but I have played Wipeout 2097 and Metal Gear Solid which are still good games, so that’s what the PS1 has going for it.

6, PS2: I mostly played this at friend’s houses when I was pretty young - a lot of Battlefront II, SingStar, and a Crazy Frog kart racer? Also Wipeout Fusion which I don’t remember being very good (but also I was bad at Wipeout then). This is at the bottom because there’s nothing I’d want to play the PS2 version of and I think PS2 games look kinda bad.

2 Likes

Looking back, I think the PS2 era was something special. There was a ton of experimentation about what games on a home console could do. Lots of games from Japan made it to the west via that console too, which opened up a whole world of things. I respect that it might well be the ultimate PS platform for most people who played during that era.

I voted PS3, because I honestly had more fun with PS3 era games. I bounced hard off some of the games that defined the PS2 era. MGS2, GTA3, and FFX didn’t click with me. I was having a better time with the games that were available for the Dreamcast. Soulcalibur, Jet Set Radio, Marvel vs Capcom, the Powerstone games, Jet Set Radio, Skies of Arcadia, etc… And for experimental, labour of love games, well, there was the PC world.

To be fair to it, I did play my PS2 enough to find out that it was a lemon. Part of that was playing more Tekken Tag Tournament than any healthy person should. I had to open that case ever other week to fix the laser alignment. Games like Shadow of the Colossus, Ico and God of War were absolute greats.

PS3 though, is when I played Demon’s Souls, Red Dead Redemption, Rock Band, Guitar Hero, Infamous, etc… It also never quit. When I finally gave it a way to the children’s hospital, it was still playing just as well as it did when I bought it. I had a hardware BC version from launch. I almost never used that feature: when I sat down to play, there was always a PS3 game that I wanted to play more than a PS2 one.

3 Likes

Yea the laser in my original PS2 also gave out eventually as well and started giving me DREs on most PS2 games. Happened kinda mid-generation so there was a bit of a gap where all I could play were PS1 games until I was able to save up enough money to buy a slim (that still works.)

3 Likes

I think I have three different answers to the question of “Favorite Playstation”

On the one hand, 2008-09 is roughly the time I started taking gaming seriously as a hobby. I played a lot of games before that, yeah, but this was the first time I was able to “keep up” as it were. Stuff like Fallout 3, New Vegas, Bioshock, Red Dead Redemption, GTA IV, Mass Effect 2, Dragon Age Origins, MGS4 and so on, were like major experiences for me. So I could say the PS3 because of sheer personal impact and nostalgia.

But on the other hand, when I think of an objectively stacked lineup, it’s impossible to not default to the PS2. The sheer amount of truly incredible, iconic, revolutionary, games on that platform feels like a lightning in a bottle situation that could never be replicated. Katamari, the Ratchet & Clank trilogy, Shadow of the Colossus, MGS 2 and 3, Okami, Persona 3, Ace Combat, God of War 2, FF10, 10-2 (dress spheres ruled, shut up), and 12 and I can go on literally forever. Not to mention that fact that it could play DVD’s and music CD’s, which for me, was like stepping into the far-flung future.

But on the other other hand, damn if I don’t find everything about the fifth generation of consoles fascinating. Developers trying to square that round hole of early 3D development are my favorite stories to read about the history of games. Like, how exactly did Hideo Kojima convince people the original Metal Gear Solid wasn’t an awful idea, because it certainly seems like one on paper. The PSX, like the Saturn and N64 to be fair, has such a “throw shit at the wall and see what sticks” vibe and I love that. Even if it feels like a nightmare to go back to some of those games now.

5 Likes

Vita 4 lyfe

Most of its greatest games were ported to other systems, and it mostly became a dumping ground of ports from other systems, but damnit I still love my little back-touching baby.

2 Likes

Respect to a huge WipEout fan :pray:

2 Likes

PSVR on the PS4 lets me hug my friends on another planet.

2 Likes

What’s that quote about the best fantasy book being whichever one you read when you were 15? I tried to look it up but Google isn’t being very helpful. Anyway, I think that may hold true for consoles too:

PS2: I don’t think I appreciated at the time how thoroughly the PS2 dominated its console cycle and what that meant for the kinds of games that appeared on it. I still had a Gamecube and Xbox at various points, but it’s hard to overstate how much the PS2 was my go-to console during a certain era. I can’t even list the ways it impacted my tastes as a gamer, because it basically defined them; this was where my MGS obsession was at its peak, my streak with JRPGs continued (another shoutout for Shadow Hearts), I started getting into horror games, and I was exposed to a ton of niche genres for the first time. I must have had gone through at least three or four separate consoles, and Persona kept me actively playing it well into the Xbox 360 era.

PS3: It’s weird to think how much I loved this one despite all of its issues. I finally got one when Heavy Rain was released (lol) and then my Xbox 360 died a few months later so it effectively became my main console for the rest of the generation. This feels like the beginning of the modern era in a lot ways; this is where I played Demon’s Souls, Dark Souls, Deus Ex: Human Revolution, Dishonored, New Vegas, Skyrim - even though some of those games are 10+ years old now, they don’t feel old to me in the same way a PS2 game does.

PSX: I was a Nintendo kid so I got this late in its life-cycle - most of my playtime with PSX games was probably through backward compatibility on the PS2 rather than the original console. Its main legacy has to be solidifying my love of JRPGs - I had no idea which were any good so I just consumed them indiscriminately; the FFs, Xenogears, Lunar 2, Chrono Cross, Legend of Dragoon, Legend of Legaia. One of my favorite memories is of playing Final Fantasy VI from the Final Fantasy Anthology collection and being absolutely bowled over by it.

PS4: This one’s placement says more about me than the actual console: sometime between the PS3 and PS4, I fell out of love with console gaming. I’m sure entering adult life, with bills and a full-time job, had a lot to do with that. Still, it’s home to Bloodborne, which might be my single favorite game ever, and it’s where I played The Witcher 3, so it’s not like it went completely ignored. I have good memories of playing through Until Dawn while my partner and our roommate watched, too. If I were five or ten years younger I’m sure I would have spent more time with it.

PSP: Most of my memories of the PSP are weird and awkward, which is fitting since I started high school not long before it came out. Lumines is the one game that stands head and shoulders above the rest for me - I got it with money my aunt sent me for my birthday one year, and then spent the rest of the summer holed up in various corners, zoning out to it via headphones. I also remember getting really excited for The Third Birthday, subsequently experiencing intense disappointment, and then finally trading in the console and most of its games for a copy of Skyrim a few months later.

And the Vita is the only Sony console I never owned, despite threatening to buy one for many years.

3 Likes

I played Battlefront 2 on my PS2, like, last week and that game still kicks ass. Thing still runs pretty well, too. PS2 forever.

4 Likes