I may be the biggest Lucha Underground evangelist on here. Like people have already said, it feels like a fun weird experiment that feels genuinely amazing at times. It does try to push itself as a very progressive promotion while still falling for some of the same old sexism in wrestling problems we have seen before. I personally think most of the intergender matches have been really good but thats just a personal opinion.
Kind of like how ECW at the time was a niche thing with a passionate audience, I feel Lucha Underground is a similar thing. It’s not a traditional wrestling promotion & that in it of itself is not for everyone. Also it’s relationship with AAA and the politics of that company rub some people the wrong way.
All that said, no other promotion has a fiewd involving a former best friends a time traveler from the future & a literal dragon.